Introducing Sully

By Chris Dempsey LM64

In February of 2013, I purchased the first coin pictured over the counter in our shop. As I always do, I went searching for matches and came up with them shortly after. The second coin listed was found on the OHNS website as part of a large collection that sold years ago in San Francisco. Coin number three sold in the 2010 OHNS auction, lot 34, for $363.

I chose the name "Sully" because the characteristics of this carver's coins tend to make the characters look dirty and unkempt: sullied. Hence the name "Sully."

Click to view enlargment. Click to view enlargment. Click to view enlargment.

The carving characteristics for "Sully" are listed as follows:

  1. Simple rounded derby. Indian's hair detail is not well removed from the derby.
  2. Derby with small wraparound ends to brim.
  3. Hair, Beard, and eyebrow as cut, likely with a knife using short curved cuts.
  4. Ear resembles a peanut shell, halved.
  5. Eye is sometimes punched.
  6. Braid sometimes, but not always completely removed.
  7. Collar made with a deep wavy cut/gash at the top.
  8. Field is nicely dressed above and behind the head.
  9. Date and Liberty left intact.